The Hidden EBITDA Killer: Why Improper Inventory Accounting Can Tank Your Business Value

When it comes to preparing a business for sale or even just tracking profitability, few things are as overlooked, and as damaging, as improperly managed inventory. For many small to mid-sized businesses, particularly those in contracting, manufacturing, or distribution, inventory accounting isn’t just a bookkeeping formality. It’s a fundamental driver of financial performance.

Let’s break down how expensing inventory when purchased (instead of putting it on the balance sheet) can significantly reduce your EBITDA and, by extension, your business valuation.

What Happens When You Expense Inventory?

Many businesses operating on a cash or modified cash basis simply expense all inventory purchases immediately. In other words, if they buy $500,000 of raw materials in a month, that entire amount hits the profit and loss (P&L) statement, even if much of that material won’t be used until future months.

This creates two key problems:

1. Mismatch of Revenue and Cost of Goods Sold (COGS):Inventory accounting is meant to match expenses with the revenues they generate. When you expense inventory upon purchase, you are recognizing costs in a period where the revenue hasn’t yet been earned. This makes your margins appear worse than they actually are.

   
   

2. Understated EBITDA:EBITDA—Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization—is a critical measure of a business’s operating performance. Overstating expenses in a given period directly reduces EBITDA, making the business appear less profitable than it truly is.

   
   

Real-World Example

Suppose a business buys $1 million of inventory in Q1 but only uses $600,000 worth of it to generate sales. If it expenses the full $1 million instead of capitalizing the unused $400,000 as inventory on the balance sheet, its P&L will show an extra $400,000 in expenses that shouldn't be there, slashing EBITDA by the same amount.

Now imagine this business is being valued at a 5x EBITDA multiple. That $400,000 mistake just cost the owner $2 million in potential value.

Why This Matters in M&A

When potential buyers or investors evaluate a business, they’re laser-focused on profitability and operational efficiency. Poor inventory accounting can:

• Undermine buyer confidence

• Lead to reduced purchase offers

• Trigger unnecessary due diligence red flags

• Delay or derail deal negotiations altogether

• 
  

Even if buyers identify and adjust for the issue during their Quality of Earnings (QoE) review, the damage to credibility can already be done.

Fixing the Problem: Capitalize and Track Inventory

To avoid this EBITDA-killing mistake:

• Implement accrual-based inventory accounting: Inventory should be treated as an asset on the balance sheet and only expensed through COGS as it's sold or consumed.

• Regularly reconcile inventory levels: This ensures your financial statements reflect real-time inventory values and consumption patterns.

• Work with a qualified CPA or financial advisor: They can help you set up inventory tracking systems and ensure GAAP-compliant accounting methods.

Conclusion

Failing to properly manage and account for inventory isn’t just a bookkeeping issue, it’s a valuation issue. By expensing inventory upfront, you may be making your business look far less profitable than it is, which can directly hurt your ability to attract buyers or secure favorable terms in a sale.

At Golden Shield Business Brokers, we help business owners implement practices that increase EBITDA, credibility, and overall value. If you’re not sure whether your inventory is helping or hurting your financials, let’s talk.